Home > About Us > J. Timothy Anderson Awards > FAQs
FAQs
1. What are the judging criteria?
A: Projects are judged on:
- Overall Design and Quality (Up to 25 pts)
- Interpretation and Respect of Historic Design Elements (Up to 25 pts)
- Innovative Approach to Construction & Use of Building Materials (Up to 15 pts)
- Impact on Surrounding Community (Up to 10 pts)
- Financial and Market Success of Project (Up to 10 pts)
- Sustainability (Up to 10 pts)
2. Who will determine the winners?
A: NH&RA gathered a diverse panel of judges with backgrounds in architecture, real estate development, construction, public policy, historic preservation and economic development.
- Josh Anderson, Cedarbend Consulting
- Lisa Craig, Chief of Historic Preservation at City of Annapolis
- John L. Kelly, Nixon Peabody LLP
- Nick Ratti, Reznick Group
- Karl Stumpf, RTKL Associates Inc.
- Brad White, Brad White & Associates
3. How should I submit my application?
A: Completed applications and attachments must be submitted in electronic format as a single, combined file. Please submit application materials and attachments as .PDF or Microsoft Office documents. Pictures/photographs should be imbedded into the applications materials, but should also be provided individually as.JPG or .GIF files. Applicants should submit applications on CD-ROM to:
National Housing & Rehabilitation Association
J. Timothy Anderson Awards c/o Greg Sidorov
1400 16th St. NW, Suite 420
Washington, DC 20036
4. I am not a developer—can I still nominate a project for a “Timmy Award”?
A: Yes, anyone may nominate a qualified project for a “Timmy Award.” Applicants are encouraged to coordinate with the entire project team as relevant to ensure a well-rounded application.
5. Who is Tim Anderson?
A: Tim Anderson was a singular figure in the preservation industry, pioneering the adaptive reuse of historic buildings. Tim’s legacy includes numerous Boston area projects as well as the seminal study that helped preserve South Beach in Miami. For more information about Tim visit: http://www.housingonline.com/BackgroundHistory.aspx.
6. I’m applying under the Best Historic Rehabilitation Involving New Construction category. What qualifies as “new construction?”
A: The “new construction” component must be new exterior construction—interior renovations alone will not qualify a project under this category. Please note projects submitted under this category must be primarily a historic rehabilitation (vs. primarily new construction).
7. What are “judges’ categories?”
A: This year, NH&RA has added two judges’ categories – Most Advanced Financial Structure and Achievement in Sustainability. Judges will select candidates for these two categories from the entire pool of applications.
8. What are judges looking for under Financial & Market Success criteria?
A: The “Timmy Awards” are development awards--successful applications should demonstrate the development’s financial success and overall marketability of the project. Applicants, should provide the judges with adequate information that indicates the project is or will be successful performing real estate asset. Suggested information may include but is not limited to lease-up, operating data and stabilization information. Notable aspects of the financial structure and obstacles overcome should also be highlighted. Be sure to include a statement about the project’s ongoing viability for the foreseeable future.
9. How do I demonstrate community benefit in my application?
A: The judges will consider overall community benefit of the project when reviewing the applications. This is especially important in the NMTC Category. Applicants may choose to highlight populations served by the project, notable tenants, community support and alignment and/or the catalyzing impact of the project.
10. My project did not involve historic tax credits—is it eligible to apply for a Timmy Award?
A: Generally speaking, most applicants utilize federal and/or state historic tax credits. Projects that did not utilize historic tax credits must demonstrate compliance with the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for Historic Preservation or similar guidelines.
11. Do you have any tips or advice on submitting a competitive application?
- Be sure you leave yourself plenty of time to compose a competitive application.
- Generally speaking, the applications that have been given the strongest consideration in previous competitions have had very strong narrative statements. Please make sure your narrative statement is thorough and emphasizes the prowess of the developer including financing, technical challenges, etc…Be sure to also address historic preservation issues and community impact of the project.
- Make sure you submit a complete application. The judges use ALL of the requested information in formulating their scores of the project. Omitted items may result in lost points in the competitive process. You’d be surprised how many applicants neglect to include all the requested information.
12. I am interested in submitting an application, but have one or more questions that are not addressed here. How can I get help with my application?
A: NH&RA will host a free conference call / webinar (date TBD) to provide an overview of the application process, as well as answer any questions from individuals planning to submit an application. Individuals may also contact NH&RA directly with questions about the application at 202-939-1750.